Though
the United States is faced with a multitude of pressures and threats every
single day, in my opinion the biggest threat to United States global influence
and dominance is the rise of China.
There is no doubt that for the past multiple decades, the United States
has been the world’s great power. Three of the most important factors in
determining a great power are the economic strength, military prowess and
international influence that a state has. Whether it is through its influence
in international affairs, the powerful economy or the dominating military
presence, the United States has been second to none on the global power scale.
However, since its massive economic growth in the last twenty years, China is
not far behind the United States in all three of these categories.
In
terms of the economic strength of both states, it is clear that even though
China has not surpassed the US economy, it is extremely close. Since the year
1990, China’s growth in GDP has surpassed 10%, making it the second highest GDP
in the world. Furthermore, in world projections, it is estimated that by the
year 2030, China and the United States would be exactly even in their GDP
levels. That being said, one of the major advantages that the US had over
China, the economy, would be taken out of the picture. Without this economic
advantage over China, the US would be left as the second most powerful country
in the world, weakening its international influence and probably causing some
form of lost trade agreements. It’s not only a matter of GDP levels or the
economic power of the two nations, but also about the crippling debt that the
US owes to China. It is believed that the US owes over 1 trillion dollars in
debt to China based on purchasing products and the cheap labor that the Chinese
provide. In this sense, if China ever decided to come collect their payments,
it would severely cripple the US economy, and would lead to severe animosity between
the two countries. China’s rise goes beyond economic power and into
international influences, which have been on the rise for China. According to a
Forbes article, “as its GDP, China has become more assertive regarding
international issues.” With increased economic power, China now has the ability
to not only influence international issues, but also be a dominating presence,
the way the US has done in the past. If China is able to have significant
influence over international issues, then what separates the United States from
China? The US has always taken pride in its ability to support international
conflicts, and alter circumstances for other nations, but they would lose that
power if China keeps developing the way it does.
If
the United States wants to remain the world’s great power, they need to place
further focus on countering China’s quick rise. Though it is unclear how the US
should try and stop the rapid development of another country, it is without
question that something needs to be done. One thing that the US may want to do
is work on cutting the incredible amount of debt they have with China.
Eradicating some of this massive debt would not only get the US out of China’s
pocket, but it would also give them more freedom to develop and improve the
economy. Furthermore, the US can show the world that they still are the world leader
in international issues. Having strong opinions, and involving themselves in
considerable issues, such as ISIS or Syria, would show the world that the US is
still the powerful influence that it has always been. Regardless of the
policies that the United States decides to take on, it is clear that something
has to be done to combat the China issue.
Yew, Lee Kuan. “China's Rise: A
Shift in Global Influence.” Forbes. N.p.
12/02/2010
Angad took a different approach to the China issue than I did in my blog. I believe he makes some good points involving the US debt to China and how that could affect our relationship. I am not sure where he is gathering the GDP information which makes me sceptical of the information, but I do believe China is gaining strong economic power.
ReplyDeleteOne thing Angad did not touch on was the military strength of China and the effects that this has on soft power/hard power. I think this is an important factor the China can use as deterrence of any other power to step in, I would like to know what approaches to China that Angad thinks would be best.
I believe it's really difficult to simply step in and try and deter a state's rise to power. Not only does it interrupt state sovereignty, which is a basic principle of American politics, but it also is simply extremely difficult. In that sense, I don't know what any organization or state can do to hinder China's development, both economically and militarily. One of the only things a state can do is strengthen itself, and make sure that after China's rise to power, they won't be economically or militarily subservient. In this sense, it is not necessarily that we need to stop China from becoming a great power, it's more that we need to make sure that we remain even stronger no matter what.
DeleteI think Angad brings up some good points in his blog. It would be foolish to neglect the fact that China is growing and catching up to the United States in various ways. As a result, they are a potential threat. While I agree we need to lessen our debt, it is easier said than done. I agree with his claim that China is rising as a world power, and we need to address this issue sooner rather than later.
ReplyDeleteAlthough Angad wrote from a different perspective as I did on this, I agree with many of the points that he makes. It is inevitable that China is growing rapidly. Because of their economic growth, they have certainly made themselves a serious threat to becoming the greatest power in international politics. Angad doesn't address the military power of China and how it stacks up against the military of the United States, which I believe is an important measure of their relative power. Either way, just like myself, Angad realizes that the US must do something to contain the rise of China if they wish to remain the greatest power in the world.
ReplyDelete